The Hottest Gay Hunks Around
These guys might be straight but they were willing to take a cock in the ass for our cameras for the very first time. It took a lot of lube, a lot of cash, and a lot of persuading to get these gay4pay muscle studs to open wide for their very first dicks. Watch military bodybuilder Trevor Mustang get plowed by Rod Barry, watch Ryan Andrews rail Andy Hunter, watch Kody Henshaw pile drive Dustin Alexanders, watch Cypher drill Erin O'Shay, and watch Justin Riddick nail Blaze!
Community
Vote on scenes, quotes, and characters for First Time Anal (2012).
The moment that still lives in your head.
Starters for First Time Anal
Your take
Rate this title
Tap half or full stars · 0.5–10 scale
Be the first Cinemoood rating
Open communitySign in to save your rating.
None yet
See all
Raw! Uncut! Video!
2021 · 1.0
Young Hunter
2020 · 6.2
Tips
2016 · 3.0
Blank Narcissus (Passion of the Swamp)
2022 · 5.4
The Fluffer
2001 · 5.8
I'm a Porn Star: Gay 4 Pay
2016 · 6.9
The Fall of Communism as Seen in Gay Pornography
1998 · 6.5
Young HOMO Show 02: Summer Time
2026
Young Rose Tribe Show 03: Season of Awakening
2026
Knife+Heart
2018 · 5.9
